How We Teach: Generalizable Education Research The effectiveness of concept mapping and retrieval practice as learning strategies in an undergraduate physiology course

Burdo J, O’Dwyer L. The effectiveness of concept mapping and retrieval practice as learning strategies in an undergraduate physiology course. Adv Physiol Educ 39: 335–340, 2015; doi:10.1152/advan.00041.2015.—Concept mapping and retrieval practice are both educational methods that have separately been reported to provide significant benefits for learning in diverse settings. Concept mapping involves diagramming a hierarchical representation of relationships between distinct pieces of information, whereas retrieval practice involves retrieving information that was previously coded into memory. The relative benefits of these two methods have never been tested against each other in a classroom setting. Our study was designed to investigate whether or not concept mapping or retrieval practice produced a significant learning benefit in an undergraduate physiology course as measured by exam performance and, if so, was the benefit of one method significantly greater than the other. We found that there was a trend toward increased exam scores for the retrieval practice group compared with both the control group and concept mapping group, and that trend achieved statistical significance for one of the four module exams in the course. We also found that women performed statistically better than men on the module exam that contained a substantial amount of material relating to female reproductive physiology.